A Place for LGBTQ Atheists, Skeptics and Humanists
Random header image... Refresh for more!

Marriage, or why I really really want same sex couples to be able to marry.

I’ve kind of been stewing for the last couple of days.  Say, since about Tuesday, when I found out that the voters of Maine had decided that they were going to deny marriage rights to same-sex couples.  And I keep going back to this question that my dad asked me when I went on a rant a couple of years back when Michigan decided to remove “common-law marriage” and ban The Same Sex Marriage, essentially ensuring that gay people and straight couples that didn’t really want a government sanctioned relationship were doomed to be legal strangers.  He asked me “Why the hell do you care so much?  It’s not like you’re gay.  Just suck it up and get married if you want those rights.”

I responded with whatever had seemed right at that particular point and time, but it’s a question that always comes back to me whenever the subject of gay marriage comes up.  My emotional tie up is more than wanting equal rights, and it’s more than fighting against religion having a bitchfit that they can’t make the government their happy fun-time bigotry playground.  I guess I have a little bit of a confession to make – I want same-sex marriage because I’m selfish.

Perhaps I should explain.

I got married at the ripe old age of twenty one, after dating the boy for over five years.  I also do not have the greatest opinion of marriage – I feel culture kind of hands us this shit ton of baggage regarding marriage and a lot of it falls on the woman.  Marriage is about “until death do us part”, not getting caught cheating instead of having honest conversation and exhibiting slightly stalkerish behavior about finding your fulfillment in one person for the rest of your life.  And there’s something wrong with you if you deviate from this.  You become a failure, a fallen woman, a harlot or a frigid bitch if your marriage doesn’t end with one of you in the grave.  If my marriage fails, society tells me it’s my fucking fault for not being/doing/whatever enough.

Before I got married, I literally sat down with a two page list with the man and went over things like religion, child raising, chore breakdown, and my big huge freakouts.  After we got through that, I realized it wasn’t him that I was worried about – it was everyone else.  It’s the government tacitly supporting women giving up their maiden name if they feel their families should be united under a single name.  It’s about the presumption that if I’m married, then you should talk to my husband, and that of course I’m running the household.  And, of course, the woman in the relationship should be giving birth to the children (who belong to her husband), and should stay at home and raise them.  If she’s going to work, she damn well better do it all – work, handle the house, raise the children and have dinner on the table when her man gets home.

These are all the things that acknowledging same-sex couples threatens.  Not that women can’t have kids and stay at home if we legally recognise gay marriage – but same-sex marriage forces all of us to have a conversation about all of this bullshit baggage that comes with the word “marriage” right now.  To decide what we want to keep and what we want to make anew.  There will be plenty of people out there who want that old-timey traditional marriage of “until death do us part”, but it shouldn’t be a foregone conclusion.  So I’ll continue to fight for marriage equality for same-sex couples, to hit the pavement and talk until people’s ears bleed, because without it, my marriage isn’t equal.  Not even close.

8 comments

1 Nonreligious Nerd { 11.06.09 at 10:07 am }

I agree wholeheartedly. The gender assumptions in our culture piss me off! im not man enough because im not a sports nut, or a car freak, or a stoic, or covertly sexist in my opinions of what a mans roles are, or what a womans are.

This comment rocks my world! Thumb up 9 Thumb down 1 (+8)

2 Craig { 11.06.09 at 12:20 pm }

One of the things I love about being gay is that I have very few gender-role expectations to live up to in my relationships because we’re both men. It’s very liberating especially compared to the very strict roles I was brought up with and lived with until I came out.

This comment rocks my world! Thumb up 8 Thumb down 1 (+7)

3 J.R. Braden { 11.06.09 at 2:46 pm }

If you don’t submit this to every blog carnival imaginable, the world will be deprived of one of the best posts on gay marriage I’ve ever read.

This comment rocks my world! Thumb up 8 Thumb down 1 (+7)

4 HedgeMonkey { 11.06.09 at 4:26 pm }

That same-sex marriage exposes the social controls inherent in traditional marriage is good point indeed. That such a phenomenal amount of marriages melt down so swiftly and horribly surely is testament that the whole institution is outdated, suspect and way due a serious face-lift. Thank you.

This comment rocks my world! Thumb up 7 Thumb down 2 (+5)

5 Michelle Bell { 11.06.09 at 4:30 pm }

@Reed Any favourites you think this should go to? I’d be willing to submit and see what other people think. I don’t know that it’ll fit with the Carnival of the Godless, which is the one I follow. I’d love suggestions.

@Craig I say that because we did the “sit down and talk about our expectations” thing, we’re infinitely more stable than we have a right to be. And I did it mostly because I watched the non-traditional and traditional families that seemed to do well, and what they all seemed to have in common was that they had a discussion about what they wanted. It’s the assumptions and the proscriptive/prescriptive ideologies that seem to be the biggest problem. My personal beef is that religion fuels a lot of this, but that’s another post entirely!

Like or Dislike: Thumb up 3 Thumb down 1 (+2)

6 Vene { 11.06.09 at 4:45 pm }

I’m glad I don’t have to stick to monogamy. Polyamorous bisexuality for the win.

Like or Dislike: Thumb up 5 Thumb down 1 (+4)

7 J.R. Braden { 11.06.09 at 8:31 pm }

CotG would run it.

Carnival of the Liberals would also love this. http://carnivaloftheliberals.com/

Like or Dislike: Thumb up 4 Thumb down 1 (+3)

8 melissacordell { 11.07.09 at 12:23 pm }

I can’t wait to see a day where gay people are treated equally under the law! Then maybe my brother can come back to the states with his new husband :)

Like or Dislike: Thumb up 3 Thumb down 2 (+1)

You must log in to post a comment.